Home›Videos›Firm Offer Tools and Alternatives›From No Deals to Five Deals a Week: A Firm Offer Tool Alternative That Works
MOTO(convert)
Video · Firm Offer Tools and Alternatives · November 19, 2026

From No Deals to Five Deals a Week: A Firm Offer Tool Alternative That Works

A Toyota store's firm offer trade tool was producing almost nothing. Mike Crothers explains what changed after the switch and why the old tool stalled.

MCMike Crothers, CEO of MOTO(acquire)
Key points
  • A Toyota store's previous firm offer style trade tool produced eight to ten leads per month and, in the store's words, no deals.

  • Mike puts the problem in a phrase: the old tool was an exact price that took six pages of work from the customer.

  • After six months on MOTO(acquire), the store says it is closing about five deals a week from the trade tool.

  • The goal is not to drop firm offers. It is to stop making every shopper do a pile of work before they see a number.

  • MOTO(convert) combines instant valuations, firm offer requests, and monthly value tracking in the website trade tool.

Plenty of dealers put a firm offer tool on their website expecting it to keep the used car lot full of trades. Then the leads came in thin, and the deals didn't come in at all. If you are looking for a firm offer tool alternative, this is the story Mike Crothers, CEO of MOTO(acquire), told after a recent visit to a Toyota store.

What changed at a Toyota store that switched trade tools

The store had been running a firm offer style trade tool on its website. In Mike's words, it was "like a firm offer, exact price, six pages of work." It brought in eight to ten leads per month, and by the store's account, none of it turned into deals.

The store has now been using MOTO(acquire) for six months. When Mike talked with the team, the answer was simple: they are closing about five deals a week from the trade tool.

That is the gap Mike wants dealers to see. Same store, same website, same kind of shopper landing on it. Different tool, different result.

Why don't firm offer tools generate leads?

Mike's diagnosis is in the phrase "six pages of work." A firm offer tool is built to produce an exact price, so it has to collect a lot of detail before it will commit to a number: condition, options, history, and more.

For the customer, that is a lot to do for a car they are only thinking about selling. Many shoppers on your site are early. They want a rough idea of what their vehicle is worth, not a project. When the tool asks for that much effort up front, a lot of them leave before you ever get a name.

The result looks exactly like what this Toyota store saw: a trickle of leads and no deals. The tool was doing what it was designed to do. It just was not designed to start conversations.

Signs your trade tool has too many steps

  • Your monthly trade leads look small next to the traffic your website gets.

  • The leads you do get rarely turn into appraisals or deals.

  • Nobody on the sales floor can remember the last deal that started in the tool.

What to look for in a firm offer tool alternative

The fix is not to stop giving firm offers. Some customers want an exact price, and your store should be ready to make one. The fix is to stop making every customer earn a number by doing six pages of work first.

When you evaluate a replacement, look for these things:

  • A fast value up front. The shopper sees a number quickly, which gives them a reason to leave contact information.

  • Firm offers as an option, not a gate. Customers who want an exact price can request it. Customers who don't are not forced through it.

  • A reason to come back. Value tracking keeps your store in front of the customer every month until they are ready to sell or trade.

  • Leads your team will actually work. A name, a vehicle, and a value give a salesperson something to talk about on the phone.

Mike has covered this from other angles too. Watch Is your firm offer tool hurting your dealership's performance? and his take on a high-volume wholesaler that does not automate its offers. You can find more in the Firm Offer Tools and Alternatives topic.

Where MOTO(convert) fits

MOTO(convert) is MOTO(acquire)'s website trade tool, the tool Mike means when he says "the trade tool." It combines instant valuations, firm offer requests, and monthly value tracking, and it includes the free buying power tool.

The idea is straightforward. Let shoppers get a value quickly, give the ones who want an exact price a way to ask for it, and keep the rest in front of you every month. That is how a website trade tool turns into conversations, and conversations turn into deals.

If your current tool is producing a handful of leads and no deals, it is worth finding out what your website could be doing instead. Start with a Dealer Website Trade-In Audit and see how many trades you are missing.

Questions

Frequently asked questions

Why do firm offer tools generate so few leads?

To give an exact price, a firm offer tool has to ask the customer for a lot of detail up front. Mike described one store's previous tool as "six pages of work." Many website shoppers are early in the process and leave before finishing, so you never get their contact information.

Can I still give customers a firm offer with MOTO(convert)?

Yes. MOTO(convert) includes firm offer requests alongside instant valuations. The difference is that the firm offer is an option for customers who want it, not a hurdle every shopper has to clear before seeing a number.

What results did the Toyota store see after switching?

Before switching, the store was getting eight to ten leads per month from its previous trade tool and no deals out of it. After six months using MOTO(acquire), the team told Mike they are closing about five deals a week from the trade tool.

Will my store see the same results?

Every store is different, and this is a single store's experience as Mike described it. What carries over is the principle: a trade tool that asks for less work up front gives your team more shoppers to talk to. A website trade-in audit is a practical way to see what your own site is leaving on the table.

Does MOTO(acquire) work with my DMS?

MOTO(acquire) integrates with all major DMS platforms and many others, including Tekion, Dealertrack, CDK, Reynolds, and Auto/Mate. If your store uses a DMS that is not integrated yet, MOTO(acquire) will build the integration.

See how many trades your website is missing

Get a walkthrough of MOTO(convert) on your own site, with instant valuations and firm offer requests in one flow. Request your Dealer Website Trade-In Audit.

Keep watching

More on Firm Offer Tools and Alternatives

Full transcript

I was at a Toyota store yesterday. The Toyota store's been using us for six months. They got eight to ten leads per month from their previous trade tool, which was like a firm offer, exact price, six pages of work. And so they got no leads, they got no deals out of it. I talked to him yesterday, he's like, we're closing about five deals a week from MOTO(acquire), the trade tool.

© 2026 Moto Acquire LLC · 222 S. Riverside Plaza, Office 15-167, Chicago, IL 60606PRIVACYTERMSDEALER TERMSYOUR PRIVACY CHOICESACCESSIBILITYCOOKIE SETTINGS