Why Are You Still Paying for More Traffic? Rethinking Used Car Acquisition Strategies for Dealers
When the store feels slow, most dealers reach for more traffic. Mike Crothers argues that instinct is costing you, and shows where your next trades are already hiding.
Most dealerships do not have a traffic problem. They have a conversion problem, and buying more traffic for a tool that does not convert just means paying more to leak the same amount out.
Lead maxing means converting the traffic you already paid for in four places: your website, your CRM, your service drive, and your salespeople's social media.
On the website, an instant valuation, a firm offer request, and monthly value tracking emails turn shoppers who used to bounce into trade-in leads.
Your service drive holds your most loyal customers, and an automated text when the RO opens can start an acquisition conversation without a dedicated team.
Giving every salesperson their own link puts social leads in the CRM with the right person getting credit, so no traffic gets lost.
When the store feels slow, the instinct is to buy more traffic. Mike Crothers, CEO of MOTO(acquire), says most dealers skip a step before they do that: checking whether the traffic they already have is converting. The most effective used car acquisition strategies for dealers start with shoppers and customers you already paid to reach, not new ones.
In Mike's words: "Pouring more into a tool that doesn't convert just means you're paying more to leak the same amount out." His answer is what he calls lead maxing. Convert what you have first, then decide if you need more.
Do you have a traffic problem or a conversion problem?
Mike's view is blunt: "You don't really have a traffic problem. You probably have a conversion problem." A lot of dealers are all doing the same thing right now, asking for more traffic and more leads through the door. That feels productive, but it does not fix a funnel that is leaking.
Before you approve another traffic budget, walk through a few questions with your used car manager:
When a shopper lands on your website, can they get a trade value and request an offer right there, or do they leave?
Are your past sales and service customers hearing from you about their vehicle's value every month?
When a repair order opens, is anyone asking that customer about selling their car?
When your salespeople post on social, where does that traffic go, and who gets credit for the lead?
If the honest answer to any of those is "not really," you have paid-for traffic that is walking out the door.
Four used car acquisition strategies for dealers that use traffic you already have
Mike points to four places your customers already are: your website, your CRM, your service drive, and your salespeople's social media. "That traffic is already paid for. Most stores just aren't converting it."
1. Your website
The fix here is simple. Give shoppers an instant valuation in under 30 seconds and let them request a firm offer on the spot. If they are not ready today, they get a value tracking email every month until they are.
Mike says that flow is averaging right around 28.2% click to lead across hundreds of dealers. "Not from brand new traffic, from the shoppers you already had on your website who used to bounce."
2. Your CRM and past customers
Everyone who has ever bought or serviced with you is sitting in your CRM. A monthly value tracking email gives them the one thing every customer cares about: what their trade is worth, whether it went up or down. They can take action right from the email, and you stay top of mind. As Mike puts it, "if you're not sending that email, another dealership is."
3. Your service drive
Your service drive is full of your most loyal customers. As soon as an RO opens, a text goes out to the customer. When they text back, the process takes off from there. You set the guardrails, adjust the messaging, and tell the system exactly which cars you want to acquire, whether or not you have a veteran service acquisition team.
4. Your salespeople's social media
Your salespeople are already posting every day and generating traffic. The problem is where that traffic goes and how you attribute it. A link in each salesperson's bio lets customers submit a lead that lands in your CRM, credited to the right person. "No more lost traffic, no more lost leads."
How MOTO(acquire) supports lead maxing
Each of the four places maps to a MOTO(acquire) product:
MOTO(convert): Website trade tool with instant valuations, firm offer requests, and monthly value tracking. Includes the free buying power tool.
MOTO(retain): Sends past sales and service customers their vehicle's value every month. Value tracking emails have a 36% open rate and 99.5% deliverability.
MOTO(drive): Service drive acquisition using DMS data and automated texts. It pushes VIN and miles to your inventory tools and alerts the sales team when a customer is ready. MOTO(drive) stores consistently buy about 1% of their repair orders without dedicated service acquisition hires.
MOTO(social): Gives each person posting on social their own link, with leads attributed in the CRM.
For more on sourcing inventory outside the lanes, see our used car sourcing without auctions hub, Mike's breakdown of how to source used cars without auction, and why your dealership doesn't need more traffic, it needs to stop the leaks.
Not more spend. Not more headcount.
Put together, that is lead maxing. Mike's summary: not more spend, not more traffic, not more headcount and more hires. Just converting the leads from the traffic you already have, so you acquire more inventory and sell more cars. If you want to see where your store is leaking, book a demo.
Frequently asked questions
What is lead maxing for car dealerships?
Lead maxing is Mike Crothers' term for converting the traffic a dealership already has instead of buying more. It focuses on four places customers already are: the website, the CRM, the service drive, and salespeople's social media. The goal is more trade-in leads and more acquired inventory without more spend or more hires.
How do I know if my dealership has a traffic problem or a conversion problem?
Look at what happens to the traffic you already get. If website shoppers leave without a trade lead, past customers never hear about their vehicle's value, service customers are never asked about selling, and social traffic has nowhere to land, you have a conversion problem. Mike's point is that more traffic poured into that setup just leaks out the same way.
How does MOTO(drive) work in the service drive?
When a repair order opens, MOTO(drive) uses DMS data to send the customer an automated text. When the customer replies, the process moves forward, VIN and miles are pushed to your inventory tools, and the sales team is alerted when the customer is ready. MOTO(drive) stores consistently buy about 1% of their repair orders without dedicated service acquisition hires.
Does MOTO(acquire) integrate with my DMS?
MOTO(acquire) integrates with all major DMS platforms and many others, including Tekion, Dealertrack, CDK, Reynolds, and Auto/Mate. If your DMS is one we do not integrate with yet, we will build the integration.
Why send customers a value tracking email every month?
Every customer cares about what their trade is worth, and a monthly value update gives them a reason to open and act. MOTO(retain) value tracking emails have a 36% open rate and 99.5% deliverability. As Mike says, if you're not sending that email, another dealership is.
See MOTO(acquire) on your website
Book a 20-minute demo and see your store's acquisition opportunity.
More on Used Car Sourcing Without Auctions
Full transcript
Car dealerships, you should be lead maxing. A lot of dealers are doing the same thing right now. They want more traffic and more leads coming in the door. And look, I get it. That's the instinct. Something feels slow, so you try to pour more into it. But here's the thing that most people don't check before they do that.
You don't really have a traffic problem. You don't need more and more traffic. You probably have a conversion problem. And pouring more into a tool that doesn't convert just means you're paying more to leak the same amount out. So here's what we're telling dealers to do instead of spending more. You're going to look at four different places your customers already are: your website, your CRM, your service drive, and your salespeople's social media.
That traffic is already paid for. Most stores just aren't converting it. On the website, it's really simple. MOTO(convert) gives shoppers an instant valuation. They can get one in under 30 seconds, and they can request a firm offer right there. Oh, and if they're not ready today, they're going to get a value tracking email every single month until they are ready to buy. That entire flow on the website, which is helping hundreds of dealers capture more trade-in leads and acquire more inventory, is averaging right around 28.2% click to lead.
Not from brand new traffic, from the shoppers you already had on your website who used to bounce. Same idea for the service drive. Your service drive is full of the most loyal customers that you have. Imagine a tool that didn't require you to have a team, or you could have the most veteran team out there. MOTO(drive) is a tool that helps you acquire more inventory from your most loyal customers.
As soon as an RO opens at the dealership, a text message goes out to the customer. That customer can then text back, and as soon as they do, the whole process takes off from there. MOTO(drive) is fully customizable, meaning you can put up guardrails, change the text messaging, and give the system the exact type of cars that you want to acquire.
MOTO(drive) is a service acquisition tool helping dealerships all around the country acquire more inventory and sell more cars directly from service. And then there's MOTO(retain). MOTO(retain) is an email that goes out to all of your past customers, as well as everybody that's ever serviced with you. This email sends them a value tracking email with the one thing every customer cares about: what their trade is worth.
So if their trade goes up in value or down in value, they're going to get this value tracking email every single month, and they're able to take action directly from there, helping you get more leads and stay top of mind with every one of your customers. Because if you're not sending that email, another dealership is. And then there's MOTO(social).
Your salespeople are already posting every single day, and they're generating leads and traffic. But where do you send all that traffic, and how do you attribute that traffic? Well, MOTO(social) helps you solve this problem. It puts a link in the bio of every one of your salespeople. When customers interact with that, they're able to submit a lead directly through it, giving your salesperson more leads, which go directly to your CRM, attributed to them so they get the credit.
No more lost traffic, no more lost leads. Everything lands in the right place and can be followed up with, so you can acquire more inventory and sell more cars. And all of those together is called lead maxing. Not more spend, not more traffic, not more headcount and more hires. Just converting the leads from the traffic that you already have. So if you want to start lead maxing at your dealership, check out the link in our bio.
All videos on Used Car Sourcing Without AuctionsSee MOTO(general)