The First iPhone Has a Lot in Common With Your Dealership Trade-In Tool
Mike Crothers holds up his original iPhone to make a point about dealership software. If your trade-in tool is from that era, here is why it may be underperforming.
Mike still has his original iPhone, which he stopped using in 2013, and the phones shoppers carry today are far more advanced than the one in his hand.
Some automotive software still in use today was launched in the early 2000s or around the same time as the first iPhones, and Mike calls that code "literally ancient."
A dealer told Mike his trade-in tool "just doesn't seem like it works very well anymore," and Mike agreed: a tool built 12 or 13 years ago was not built for today's devices.
If your trade-in tool was built 10-plus years ago and you are wondering why it is not converting, the age of the software is a good place to start looking.
Mike says MOTO(acquire)'s tools were built with code written in the last year, year and a half, are high converting, and work on a mobile device.
Is my dealership trade-in tool outdated? It is a fair question if your website gets traffic but the trade-in leads are thin. Mike Crothers, co-founder and CEO of MOTO(acquire), makes the case with something sitting on his desk: the original iPhone. If your trade tool was built around the same time that phone was new, it was built for a different internet.
What the original iPhone says about your software stack
Mike still has his original iPhone. Plug it in and it charges and turns on. He stopped using it in 2013, about 13 years ago, and the phone he films on today is, in his words, "so much more technologically advanced" that it is "just mind-blowing."
Software ages the same way. Some automotive software companies launched products in the early 2000s, and that software is still running in dealerships today. The phones your customers carry have changed completely. A lot of the tools on dealer websites have not.
Mike had just gotten off a call with a dealer who said the trade-in tool his store was using "just doesn't seem like it works very well anymore." Mike agreed. That product came out 12 or 13 years ago, around the time iPhones looked like the one in his hand. Of course it is not going to work really well with the devices shoppers use today.
Is my dealership trade-in tool outdated? How to tell
In Mike's view, a code base that old is "literally ancient." Since then there have been countless updates, new coding languages, and now AI that writes code. A tool can still load and technically work while falling behind on the experience shoppers expect.
If you are asking why your trade-in tool is not converting, start with a few practical checks:
Run it on your own phone. Go through the trade-in flow the way a customer would, start to finish, on a mobile device. Note anywhere you have to pinch, zoom, scroll sideways, or wait.
Know when it was built. Ask your vendor when the product launched and when the core code was last rebuilt, not just when the design was refreshed.
Look at what you are getting out of it. If the traffic is there but the trade leads are not, the tool itself deserves a hard look before you blame the market.
Listen to your team. If your used car manager or BDC says the tool just does not work very well anymore, take it seriously. That is exactly what the dealer told Mike.
Mike's bottom line: if you are using tools built 10-plus years ago and you are trying to figure out why it isn't converting, or why you are not getting as much out of it as you would like, the age of the software is a good place to look.
Replacing legacy dealership software with something built for mobile
Replacing a tool that has been on your site for years feels like a project. But leaving it in place has a cost too: every shopper who gives up on a clunky trade form on their phone is a vehicle you never got a chance to buy.
Mike's pitch is simple. MOTO(acquire)'s tools were built with code written in the last year, year and a half. He describes them as high converting, built to work on a mobile device, and "built with intention." He is the co-founder and CEO, he shows up every day, and the engineers work in the office with him. As he puts it, they try to make the best, highest converting software they can "because we have to."
Where MOTO(convert) fits
MOTO(convert) is MOTO(acquire)'s website trade tool. It gives shoppers instant valuations and firm offer requests, adds monthly value tracking, and includes the free buying power tool. It is built for dealers who want a mobile-first trade-in tool on their website.
For more on this topic, see the Website Trade-In Leads hub, Mike's take on getting more website trade-in leads, and what makes the best trade-in tool for dealerships.
Stop using software that's stuck in the past
Mike's closing message is direct: stop using software that's been stuck in the past. If your trade tool predates the phones your customers are holding, book time with the MOTO(acquire) team at motoacquire.com and see how a current build performs on your site.
Frequently asked questions
How do I know if my dealership trade-in tool is outdated?
Ask your vendor when the product launched and when the core code was last rebuilt. Then run the trade-in flow yourself on a phone, start to finish. If the tool dates back 10-plus years and feels clunky on mobile, Mike's view is that it was built for devices your shoppers no longer use.
Why is my trade-in tool not converting?
There can be several reasons, but Mike points to the age of the software as a common one. A tool built 12 or 13 years ago was not designed for today's phones, and coding has moved on with new languages and AI. If traffic is steady but trade leads are not, the tool itself is worth a hard look.
Does it really matter if old dealer software works on mobile devices?
Yes. Your shoppers are on phones that are far more advanced than the ones these older tools were built around. If the trade-in experience is awkward on a mobile device, shoppers can leave before they ever submit their vehicle.
What does MOTO(convert) include?
MOTO(convert) is MOTO(acquire)'s website trade tool with instant valuations, firm offer requests, and monthly value tracking. It also includes the free buying power tool. Mike says MOTO(acquire)'s tools were built with code written in the last year, year and a half, and work on a mobile device.
Will MOTO(acquire) work with my DMS?
MOTO(acquire) integrates with all major DMS platforms and many others, including Tekion, Dealertrack, CDK, Reynolds, and Auto/Mate. If your DMS is not one MOTO(acquire) integrates with yet, the team will build the integration.
See how many trades your website is missing
Get a walkthrough of MOTO(convert) on your own site, with instant valuations and firm offer requests in one flow.
More on Website Trade-In Leads



Full transcript
This is the original iPhone. This actually still works. If I plugged this in, it would charge up and it would still turn on. Now, what's crazy about this phone is that I stopped using this in 2013, about 13 years ago. Think about how much phones have changed in the last 13 years. It's pretty crazy. The phone that I'm currently filming this on is so much more technologically advanced than this phone.
It's just mind-blowing. So when you think about that in terms of software, there are companies that built their software around that time. Think about the early 2000s. Some automotive software companies came out, launched software, and that software is still in use today. And I literally just got off a call with a dealer two minutes ago and he was like, yeah, this trade-in tool that we're using, it just doesn't seem like it works very well anymore.
And I had to agree and say, hey, that company came out with that product 12, 13 years ago, around the same time as the iPhones looked like this. And so if you think about it, of course it's not going to work really, really well with the devices that are being used today. In terms of code bases, that software code is literally ancient.
There have been so many more updates, and even new coding languages have come about. And now, of course, we have AI that writes code and all of that, too. So if you're a dealer who's using tools that were built 10-plus years ago and you're trying to figure out why isn't this converting, why am I not getting as much out of this as I would like, then you should probably talk to us at MOTO(acquire). Go to motoacquire.com and book some time with us.
We'll help you. Our tools were built with code that was written in the last year, year and a half. Really high converting. Works perfectly on a mobile device. Built with intention. I'm the co-founder and CEO here. I show up every day. Our engineers are all here in the office with me. And we just try to make the best, highest converting software that we can because we have to. Stop using software that's been stuck in the past. Use MOTO(acquire). Go to motoacquire.com.
